Advantages of Bankruptcy when Closing a Business

When closing a small business, there are advantages to using Bankruptcy as a means to winding up your small business.  If you're Going Out of Business and are looking for alternatives to Bankruptcy, or a more detailed discussion on bankruptcy advantages, then you must read Gordon Eng's recent article in the Los Angeles Lawyer magazine of the Los Angeles County Bar Association entitled, Going Out of Business

The advantages of using Bankruptcy as a means of closing your small business include having the Court judicially assist in winding up the financial affairs of the business by providing a single forum for contesting the validity of creditor's claims.  The Court also provides a valuable mechanism for the liquidation of the debtor's assets and determining the allocation among the creditors based upon their priority in a chapter 7 bankruptcy.  After the business has been liquidated and distributed among the creditors, any remaining debt is usually discharged.

Debts that cannot be discharged in a bankruptcy are

  • Federal, state and local taxes
  • Family support; i.e., spousal and/or child support
  • Student Loans, absent undue hardship
  • Secured debts
  • Government imposed fines or penalties
  • Fraud and punitive damage claims

A small business may file a chapter 7 bankruptcy as a corporation or LLC., otherwise the business owner must file a personal bankruptcy.  If the business is not incorporated and the owner files a personal bankruptcy, they are subject to the means test in determining whether they qualify for a chapter 7, or if they must file under chapter 13. 

Business owners who are shutting their doors would be wise to consult with an attorney who can help them work through the issues of closing a business in the most efficient manner that limits or eliminates their financial and legal exposure. 

Tax Consequences of Restructuring Bad Debt

The November, 2009 issue of ABA Journal article entitled, The Bad-Debt Blues, explained the need to take federal taxes into consideration when restructuring debt as, "crucial."  The article provides an excellent overview of the federal tax rules that apply to debt workouts, and focuses on the impact to individual debtors.

The recent media blitz touting the end of the recession is an illusion caused only by government spending.  Bankruptcy filings are still up over last year and climbing to record numbers since the BAPCPA in 2005. Americans continue to struggle with what to do about their debt.

The so-called housing bubble we appear to be experiencing is caused by the fact that banks are holding foreclosed homes in their inventory rather than selling them because putting them on the market will only reduce already depressed housing values.  Similarly, the banks are also refraining from foreclosing on homes and moving toward more workout programs and modifications because they're starting to realize the error of their greedy ways. 

When faced with the tax consequences of the restructuring of individual consumer debt; either through foreclosure, repossession, or modification; filing bankruptcy provides a safe harbor and important IRS exclusions.  There is another exclusion under the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act of 2007 that applies to Qualified Principal Residence Indebtedness on or after Jan. 1, 2006. 

It is important to remember that most financial transactions have tax consequences and we all know that ignoring the IRS with its hand out is never a good idea.  Consult with your lawyer to fully understand the tax consequences and restructure debt in the way that best minimizes tax liabilities for you. 

Chapter 7 Basics

In determining eligibility to file for a chapter 7 bankruptcy, the basic qualifying factor is income under the Means Test as set forth in 11 U.S.C. 707(b)(2).  The debtor's income must fall below the Census Bureau's Median Income by Family Size.   Thus, the Means Test is a two prong test:

  • The first prong being the size of the household; and
  • The second prong being that of the debtor's gross income for the six months preceding the bankruptcy filing. 

Debts generally not dis chargeable in Chapter 7 bankruptcy include:  taxes, child or family support payments, student loans [absent undue hardship], traffic tickets, government fines, alcohol related accident judgments, judgment for willful or malicious conduct resulting in serious physical injury or death.

Debtors are required to submit a copy of their recent tax transcripts to the Trustee prior to the meeting of creditors, 11. U.S.C. 341(a).  A copy of the tax transcripts can be obtained by the debtor by calling the IRS 1-800-829-1040 and the debtor can even authorize the transcripts be faxed directly to counsel.  The IRS attorney line for transcripts is 1-866-860-4259

In California, their are certain exemptions that can be taken under California Code of Civil Procedure Sections 703, 704.  Exemptions allow a person to keep certain assets after the bankruptcy.  You must select only one set of exemptions.  If spouses are filing jointly, they must select the same set of exemptions.

A qualified bankruptcy attorney will review your individual financial situation and determine whether you qualify for chapter 7 or need to file chapter 13 bankruptcy.