Can I Keep My Income Tax Refund In Bankruptcy?

Are you one of those people that gets a large tax refund every year and you pay bills; or take a vacation with it?  You're providing the federal government with a free, no interest loan on YOUR money if you do. MSN posted this article, How to Adjust your Tax Withholdings, which provides a step-by-step guide to show you how to adjust your tax withholdings to put more money each paycheck in your pocket.  Why should you do this you ask? 

Besides the fact that you're loaning your money to the government free of interest and you know they would never reciprocate the sentiment, you're needlessly tying up your money in an account you cannot access but once a year when your big fat refund arrives. Besides, if you need to file bankruptcy, the trustee has the power to take that tax refund to pay creditors.

Taking charge of your money requires a disciplined approach.  Creating a budget  that includes your monthly bills is the first step.  You also need to include those annual bills like insurance and taxes and set up a savings account, making regular monthly deposits to be sure the money is there when the bills arrive.  I know savings rates are low, but it's better than tying up your money for a year and making nothing for handing it over to the feds for a while.

When it comes to filing bankruptcy under Chapter 7, the trustee's job is to look for assets to take from you to pay your creditors.  Any tax return greater than $500.00 can and will be taken by the trustee.  Adjusting your income tax withholding is an easy remedy for you to not only break even at tax time, but leave nothing for the trustee to take to pay creditors.  Consult your tax advisor and your bankruptcy lawyer  to create the best strategy for you.

Bankruptcy Can Be Cheaper, Better, and Faster than Debt Settlement

I know what you've been told because I have heard it all too.  The government wants you to do your very best to avoid bankruptcy at all cost.  Bankruptcy is bad; or at least, a harsh remedy to dealing with debt, and should be your last resort.  We have all bought into this 'agreement reality' and it couldn't be further from the truth.

I assert, bankruptcy is a powerful tool that should be considered in your overall financial plan that includes eliminating debts.  Adrian Lapas, over at Bankruptcy Law Network explained the pitfalls of debt settlement by warning of 1099 tax bills for canceled debts; and even creditor's unwillingness to negotiate a settlement at all.  Oh, and I'm really tired of discussing your credit  score because it's already been adversely affected by your not making your payments on time. In fact, filing bankruptcy might actually improve your credit score once all that bad debt is cleared from your credit report. 

I've had clients come to me after signing up with these debt settlement companies and spending nearly $10,000 on fees, only to find themselves in lawsuits with their creditors that these companies warned them about and would not help them with.  Remember that if you negotiate your settled debts, you're still paying money toward them and you'd better have some cash saved up to pay it in full if they accept your offer.  Also, you must be prepared for that 1099 tax bill at the end of the year because you'll wind up paying taxes on that can celled debt.

Bankruptcy not only eliminates the debt without any payments from you, it will eliminate your liability entirely and you won't owe taxes on the debts that were discharged in the bankruptcy.  That's where bankruptcy as a tool, is more efficient and not only a powerful tool, but a cost saving device for you as well.

Can I Fund My IRA Before I File For Bankruptcy?

Let's talk about your retirement accounts as they relate to your decision to file for bankruptcy.  There are many varieties and vehicles for retirements savings that include pensions, 401k, 403b, IRA and Roth IRA accounts.  Perhaps there are others that I am not aware of.  As I have said before, DO NOT CASH OUT YOUR RETIREMENT TO PAY YOUR DEBTS.  Your retirement accounts are ONLY for retirement and should NEVER be accessed for any other reason. 

When you file bankruptcy, all of your assets become a part of your estate.  The trustee will have temporary control over that estate and can administer certain assets to pay debts.  However, some assets in your estate, including retirement accounts are exempt from being taken by the trustee. 

One great reason to hire an attorney to assist you in filing bankruptcy is pre-bankruptcy planning.  Your attorney will give you valuable advice before filing your bankruptcy case.  Converting non-exempt assets to exempt assets before filing a bankruptcy is not only non-fraudulent, your attorney has a duty to maximize this type of pre-bankruptcy planning.  Keep in mind the CA IRA has a "reasonably necessary" for retirement limit, in addition to limitations of contributions to only the tax deductible amount for each tax year.

The good news is yes, you can fund that IRA before filing bankruptcy.  Be sure to consult with your personal bankruptcy lawyer to ensure you're taking full advantage of your exemption rights.

Don't Settle Debts Before Filing Bankruptcy

The only reason you should negotiate directly with your creditors, is to avoid bankruptcy.  Remember that working with debt settlement companies is both costly and detrimental to your finances and will likely land you in my office filing for bankruptcy.  If you want to avoid bankruptcy, work directly with your creditors for an agreement on what your debt is worth.  If they even think you're about to file for bankruptcy, they will most likely make some kind of offer.  However, settling debts to avoid bankruptcy comes with a price;  Income Taxes!

Beware that if you settle, or negotiate a debt to avoid bankruptcy, you could end up getting a tax bill.  while the IRS is forgiving settled debt where mortgages are concerned; the California Franchise Tax Board is not because their program has expired.  So, in California, you'll wind up owing state income taxes, if the debt you settled relates to a secured mortgage in a short sale.

But what about your credit cards?  Unsecured debt negotiations and settlements will be taxed by both the state and federal agencies.  So, unless you're prepared to pay taxes on the amount that will be written off by your creditor, then, like Cathy Moran said in her blog, Should I Settle Some Debts Before Bankruptcy, your money could be put to better use, like saving for retirement.

Tax Consequences of Restructuring Bad Debt

The November, 2009 issue of ABA Journal article entitled, The Bad-Debt Blues, explained the need to take federal taxes into consideration when restructuring debt as, "crucial."  The article provides an excellent overview of the federal tax rules that apply to debt workouts, and focuses on the impact to individual debtors.

The recent media blitz touting the end of the recession is an illusion caused only by government spending.  Bankruptcy filings are still up over last year and climbing to record numbers since the BAPCPA in 2005. Americans continue to struggle with what to do about their debt.

The so-called housing bubble we appear to be experiencing is caused by the fact that banks are holding foreclosed homes in their inventory rather than selling them because putting them on the market will only reduce already depressed housing values.  Similarly, the banks are also refraining from foreclosing on homes and moving toward more workout programs and modifications because they're starting to realize the error of their greedy ways. 

When faced with the tax consequences of the restructuring of individual consumer debt; either through foreclosure, repossession, or modification; filing bankruptcy provides a safe harbor and important IRS exclusions.  There is another exclusion under the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act of 2007 that applies to Qualified Principal Residence Indebtedness on or after Jan. 1, 2006. 

It is important to remember that most financial transactions have tax consequences and we all know that ignoring the IRS with its hand out is never a good idea.  Consult with your lawyer to fully understand the tax consequences and restructure debt in the way that best minimizes tax liabilities for you. 

Federal Income Tax in Chapter 7 Bankruptcy

Generally, taxes are treated the same as other debts in a chapter 7 bankruptcy case.  Taxes may be treated as secured, unsecured, or non-priority unsecured, or some combination.  IRS Code, found in 26 U.S.C. 6321, states that the government is secured if it has recorded a notice of lien.  Taxes that have been recorded as a  lien are a priority and must be paid in bankruptcy and cannot be discharged.  

A colleague of mine,  John Greifendorf, addressed the question, Can I discharge Federal Income Tax in Bankruptcy?  His article is concise and outlines five conditions for discharging what the debtor owes to the IRS and even sets forth and example to follow. 

The Five Conditions are:

  1. The due date for filing the tax return was not less than three years ago
  2. The tax return was filed at least two years ago
  3. The tax assessment is at least 240 days old
  4. The tax return was not fraudulent
  5. The tax payor is not guilty of tax evasion

If the debtor meets the qualifications, then the tax liability is not a priority and is discharged in bankruptcy; 11 U.S.C. 523(a)(1).  Unsecured taxes that are deemed a priority, fall outside the scope of the conditions discussed by Mr. Greifendorf and cannot be discharged in bankruptcy.

Timing is a critical component in deciding to file for bankruptcy protection and the advice of a bankruptcy attorney will address this issue.  Best practices include filing all tax returns prior to filing a bankruptcy petition with the court.  Seek the advice of a CPA or tax attorney regarding IRS claims.