I was talking the other day with Scott Schang, branch manager at Broadview Mortgage, Katella Branch in Orange Ca. who is also the Dean of Home Ownership University blog. Our lively conversation centered upon our common goal to bring TRUTH to the consumers and he struck a cord with me when he mentioned his blog article entitled, Buy Again After Bankruptcy, Short Sale, or Foreclosure? received over 400 comments. Some of these comments shocked me when Scott explained some of the things consumer bankruptcy attorneys are telling their clients. I know there are two sides to every story and I've had to explain complex legal matters several times and break it down in "civilian" terms, so my clients could understand what was actually happening. So, it's either the attorneys giving incorrect information, or the consumer misunderstood what the attorney was trying to explain. Miscommunication or Malpractice? I'll stay neutral and try to break it down for you here.
When a consumer files for bankruptcy, they are required to list all of their assets ("stuff") and all of their liabilities ("debts" and payment obligations "bills") on their bankruptcy petition papers and schedules. This includes your HOME. And NO, you cannot keep your home out of the bankruptcy because it is part of your bankruptcy estate when you file bankruptcy. So, you list your home and its value, then you list the mortgage company and what you owe them.
When you receive your bankruptcy discharge, your legal obligation to pay on that mortgage is permanently discharged. This means that IF you never made another mortgage payment ever again, the lender could not come after you to collect on that debt.
HOWEVER, here in California, if you have a mortgage, that lender also holds a LIEN against your home. So, while they will NOT be able to collect on your mortgage, they can still FORECLOSE on your home, if you choose not to pay your mortgage. So, this means that if you intend to keep your home, you MUST continue to make your mortgage payments.
NOTE: YOU ARE THE LEGAL OWNER OF YOUR HOME
UNTIL TITLE TRANSFERS TO ANOTHER OWNER, OR BACK TO THE BANK!!!!
If you intend to surrender your home, then you have several options.
1. Foreclosure: If you want to re-enter the market and buy a home in the future, this is NOT the route to take. As Scott mentions quite frequently in his blog, mortgage lenders make you wait longer to qualify for a mortgage after a foreclosure. The other reason that this is not your best option are found in the blog comments where folks are stuck in limbo because the banks are delaying these foreclosures due to missing paperwork. You simply do not have control over when the foreclosure will happen and this leads to uncertainty about moving on with your life.
2. Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure: In this transaction, you are deeding the home back to the bank. This is NOT ideal because it's still not solving the the banks problem. You see, banks are not in the business of owning homes, they want to get paid on the debt. Also, this may be better in some states than others, so I encourage you consult with your local attorney and learn about all your options before deciding the best route to take.
3. Short Sale: In my opinion, this is the best option, if the bank approves it. What you're doing here is actually selling your home to a bona fide buyer for less than what you owe. When title transfers to this new owner, the bank gets to offload the house and satisfies part of the debt you owe and the bank benefits in these transactions. The consumer benefits because they will qualify for a new mortgage much sooner than with any other options. Also, until the end of this year, the IRS and in CA, the Franchise Tax Board are waiving income taxes on canceled debt where a mortgage is involved.
I encourage every consumer to consult with their tax professional, and attorney before making important financial decisions such as these.
Photo Credit: Sean Dreilinger